At Cafferty & Scheidegger, we are committed to defending our clients with precision and resolve. We are pleased to share that on February 12, 2025, felony charges against our client, Elijah J. Schoffstall, a 21-year-old Carthage College student, were dismissed in Kenosha County Circuit Court. This resolution, achieved after nearly two years of diligent effort, reflects our unwavering dedication to upholding justice.
The case originated from a May 2023 motor vehicle accident near Carthage College, resulting in two felony counts and a misdemeanor charge against Mr. Schoffstall. The allegations carried significant consequences, including the potential for substantial prison time. Our firm undertook a thorough examination of the evidence, collaborating with experts to analyze DNA recovered from the vehicle’s airbag. Presented with the evidence by our team the Kenosha County District Attorney’s Office acknowledged the insufficiency of their case, leading to the dismissal of all charges.
Throughout this process, our team, led by Patrick Cafferty, remained focused on the facts and the law. Mr. Schoffstall consistently maintained his innocence, and we worked diligently to ensure his voice was heard. We extend our appreciation to the Kenosha Police and Fire Departments for their efforts in responding to the incident, while emphasizing our role in securing a just outcome for our client.
For over three decades, Cafferty & Scheidegger has represented individuals across Southeastern Wisconsin—Racine, Kenosha, and surrounding communities—with a steadfast commitment to excellence in criminal defense. This case exemplifies our approach: meticulous preparation, strategic advocacy, and a deep respect for our clients’ rights.
If you or someone you know faces criminal charges, we invite you to contact us at 262-632-5000 or visit racinelaw.com for a complimentary consultation. At Cafferty & Scheidegger, we stand ready to provide the sophisticated, effective representation you deserve.
Why Choose Cafferty
Free Consultation
From our offices in Racine and Kenosha Wisconsin, the criminal defense lawyers at Cafferty & Scheidegger defend the rights of people charged with state and federal criminal offenses throughout Southeastern Wisconsin (Racine, Kenosha, Walworth). If you or a loved one is charged with a crime, contact us today to arrange a free initial consultation with an experienced Racine federal criminal defense attorney right away. For urgent matters, you are welcome to call or text us 24 hours a day at (262) 632-5000.
We Defend You
The attorneys at Cafferty & Scheidegger have excellent knowledge of the state and federal court system throughout Southeastern Wisconsin. They are aggressive trial lawyers that are recognized for integrity and hard work. Our law firm’s strength lies in our exceptional pre-trial investigation and case preparation. We come to the prosecutor’s office prepared with the facts and ready to help you get the best possible outcome for your charges. Our priority is always to keep you out of jail and avoid a conviction on your record, whenever possible.
Proven Experience
The dedication of the team at Cafferty & Scheidegger to client service and their record of success has earned them listings as Wisconsin Super Lawyer® from 2008 through 2022. In addition, their reputation for high standards has earned them an AV Distinguished rating by Martindale-Hubbell. Cafferty & Scheidegger is backed by more than 28 years of trial skills and courtroom experience.
Contact us today for a free consultation
We are here to help you with your law questions.