Cafferty, Scheidegger & Johnson on Facebook Cafferty, Scheidegger & Johnson on X Cafferty, Scheidegger & Johnson on LinkedIn
Call or Text us Phone Mobile (262) 632-5000 Email Start your case review Español
Cafferty, Scheidegger & Johnson, S.C. Español
Practice Area

Probation Holds, Revocation and Appeals in Racine and Kenosha

On a probation hold in Racine or Kenosha? Wisconsin gives DOC 15 working days to start a preliminary hearing and 50 days for the final one. What to do now.

Start your case review Call (262) 632-5000

Do You Need a Racine Probation Violation Lawyer?

If you are a resident of Southeastern Wisconsin seeking help with an appeal for a previous criminal conviction, or are facing legal problems because of a violation of the terms of your probation or parole, contact Cafferty, Scheidegger & Johnson, S.C., in Racine and Kenosha.

The team at Cafferty, Scheidegger & Johnson includes experienced criminal defense attorneys who have earned a reputation among prosecutors, judges, and probation officers for integrity and honest hard work. The firm has been recognized with Wisconsin Super Lawyer® listings from 2008 through 2026. In addition, the team’s reputation for high standards has earned an AV Preeminent rating by Martindale-Hubbell.

The Governing Wisconsin Statutes

The law at a glance

Probation and its conditions are set out at § 973.09. The court has broad authority to impose conditions of probation reasonably related to the defendant’s rehabilitation and public safety. If the Department of Corrections believes a condition has been violated, the statute controls the process that follows, from the hold and preliminary hearing through final revocation.

Criminal appeals in Wisconsin proceed under § 809.30, which sets the 20-day notice-of-intent deadline and the post-conviction motion framework. Missing that deadline forecloses most appellate rights, which is why early consultation after sentencing is critical.

At the revocation hearing, the State carries only a preponderance-of-the-evidence burden, not the reasonable-doubt standard of trial. That lower burden is part of why preparation and advocacy at the hearing itself are so important. A reinstatement with additional conditions is often available where revocation would otherwise mean time back in custody.

Post-conviction defense

Probation violations and appeals require a different clock

After sentencing, the deadlines are shorter and the pressure points are different. Probation violations often start with a hold and administrative hearing track. Appeals start with a notice-of-intent deadline. Expungement, sentence modification, and collateral motions each have their own rules. We triage these issues quickly so one missed deadline does not close the best route.

Probation hold

If the Department of Corrections places someone on a hold, the defense should immediately identify the alleged violation, available witnesses, treatment compliance, employment history, and alternatives to revocation. Technical violations and new-law violations need different defense plans.

Revocation hearing

Final revocation hearings are administrative, not jury trials, but the outcome can send someone to jail or prison. We prepare evidence for reinstatement, alternatives to revocation, disputed facts, and mitigation before the hearing becomes a one-sided report.

Appeal and postconviction review

Direct appeal rights are tied to § 809.30. Sentence modification, plea withdrawal, ineffective assistance, and § 974.06 claims require a different analysis than a standard revocation defense.

  • Calendar the 20-day notice-of-intent deadline after sentencing.
  • Build a revocation packet with treatment records, employment records, housing, witnesses, and mitigation.
  • Challenge whether revocation is necessary, not just whether a violation occurred.
  • Review Wisconsin expungement eligibility before and after sentence completion.
§ 973.09Probation authority and conditions § 973.10Probation revocation procedure § 809.30Direct criminal appeal deadlines § 974.06Collateral postconviction motions

What a probation hold is, and how long Wisconsin can keep you on one

A probation hold is a detention ordered by your Department of Corrections agent, not by a judge, when the agent believes a rule of supervision has been broken. You are booked into the Racine County Jail or the Kenosha County Detention Center and held without bail while DOC decides whether to seek revocation. Nothing about a hold is automatic, and two statutes govern how long it can last and what has to happen next.

The clocks that start the day of the hold

Under § 302.335(2)(a), when a probationer, parolee or person on extended supervision is detained in a county jail, DOC must begin a preliminary revocation hearing within 15 working days (extendable by up to 5 working days for cause). Under § 302.335(2)(b), the Division of Hearings and Appeals must begin the final revocation hearing within 50 calendar days of the detention (extendable by up to 10 calendar days at DOC’s request). Revocation itself proceeds under § 973.10(2); parole and extended-supervision revocations run under § 304.06(3). Days on a hold for the same course of conduct count toward the eventual sentence under § 973.155(1)(b).

What we do in the first 48 hours of a hold

  • Call the agent and the supervisor. A hold is discretionary. Proof of housing, employment, treatment compliance and a concrete plan is what gets holds lifted before any hearing.
  • Separate the two cases. When the alleged violation is also a new charge, anything said to the agent can reach the prosecutor. We coordinate both so the revocation defense does not damage the criminal defense.
  • Prepare the preliminary hearing. If the agent will not release, the § 302.335(2)(a) hearing is the first place to contest probable cause. Waiving it is sometimes right and sometimes a mistake; that is a decision to make with counsel, not on the jail intake form.
  • Build the alternative-to-revocation packet. Treatment placement, employer letters, family support and a supervision plan. Administrative law judges reinstate people who arrive with a plan far more often than people who arrive with an apology.
  • Track the sentence credit. Booking dates from the jail record, so every day on the hold is credited under § 973.155 if the case ends in a sentence.

This is the work behind the questions people search for the day a family member is taken into custody: what a hold is, how long it can last, and how it gets lifted. The answers are in the FAQ below, and they are the same answers we give on the phone at (262) 632-5000.

I Violated My Probation. Will I Go To Jail?

Probation can be part of a punishment for a crime. Probation involves restrictions for a determined period of time on the activities of a person. When people violate probation, they can have their probation revoked and could serve time in jail. Most probation violations are the result of mistakes or misunderstandings by the part of the person serving probation. We will work aggressively to help you defend your freedom by presenting mitigating circumstances that can help sway a judge to reinstate the probation or give an alternate punishment such as treatment instead of serving jail time.

How We Can Help You

Our firm’s reputation is based on our capacity to investigate options thoroughly and alternatives that make sense. We have excellent knowledge of the state and federal criminal justice system throughout Southeastern Wisconsin. Our Racine and Kenosha probation violation lawyers come to hearing rooms and prosecutors’ offices prepared with the facts and ready to help you get the best possible outcome for your charges.

Related post-conviction help: Wisconsin expungement and record-clearing strategy, misdemeanor defense, and county court guides for Racine, Kenosha, and Walworth.

Contact an Experienced Racine Probation Violation Attorney

From offices in Racine and Kenosha, WI, the criminal defense team at Cafferty, Scheidegger & Johnson defends the rights of people charged with state and federal criminal offenses throughout Southeastern Wisconsin. Contact the firm to arrange a free initial consultation with an experienced Racine and Kenosha probation violation attorney right away.

Call Start your case review

Frequently Asked Questions

What is a probation hold in Wisconsin?
A probation hold is a detention ordered by a Department of Corrections agent, not a judge, when the agent believes you violated a rule of probation, extended supervision or parole. You are taken to the county jail (Racine County Jail or Kenosha County Detention Center) and held while DOC investigates and decides whether to seek revocation under § 973.10(2). There is no bail on a hold. The hold can be lifted by the agent at any time, which is why the first job is to get the agent the facts that support release: the nature of the alleged violation, treatment and employment records, and a plan. Cafferty, Scheidegger & Johnson, S.C. handles holds and revocations in Racine and Kenosha from offices in both cities; call (262) 632-5000 the day the hold is placed.
How long can a probation hold last in Wisconsin?
Wisconsin sets two clocks in § 302.335(2). If you are held in a county jail, DOC must begin a preliminary revocation hearing within 15 working days of the detention (extendable by up to 5 working days for cause), and the Division of Hearings and Appeals must begin the final revocation hearing within 50 calendar days (extendable by up to 10 days on DOC's request). The preliminary hearing is skipped if you waive it in writing, admit the violation in writing, or a court has already found probable cause in a felony case for the same conduct. If those deadlines are missed, § 302.335(3) requires the jail to notify DOC and, absent a timely hearing, release you from the hold. In practice many holds end sooner because the agent lifts them once a plan is in place.
How do you get a probation hold lifted?
Persuade the agent, and if that fails, use the hearing. A hold is discretionary, so a defense lawyer's first call is to the agent and the agent's supervisor with the facts that make continued detention unnecessary: proof of a stable residence and job, treatment enrollment or compliance records, the other side of the alleged violation, and a written alternative to revocation. Where the alleged violation is also a new criminal charge, we coordinate the two cases so nothing said to the agent hurts the criminal defense. If the agent will not lift the hold, the preliminary hearing under § 302.335(2)(a) is the first forum to contest probable cause, and the final hearing before an administrative law judge is where revocation itself is decided.
Is revocation automatic after a probation violation in Wisconsin?
No. A violation gives DOC the option to seek revocation; it does not require it. Under § 973.10(2) the department may initiate revocation before the Division of Hearings and Appeals, and the administrative law judge decides after a hearing whether the violation is proved by a preponderance of the evidence and whether revocation, rather than reinstatement with new conditions or an alternative to revocation (ATR), is the appropriate response. Many technical violations, a missed appointment, a positive test, a late report, end in a warning, additional conditions or a short ATR program rather than revocation. What tends to produce revocation is a new offense, absconding, or a pattern of violations with no plan on the table.
What happens at a probation revocation hearing?
The final revocation hearing is an administrative hearing before an administrative law judge of the Division of Hearings and Appeals, not a jury trial. DOC presents the alleged violations, usually through the agent, and must prove them by a preponderance of the evidence. You have the right to counsel, to present witnesses and documents, and to cross-examine. The judge then decides two questions: whether a violation occurred, and whether revocation is warranted rather than reinstatement or an alternative. If probation is revoked, the case returns to the sentencing court for sentencing under § 973.10(2), or the withheld or stayed sentence takes effect. The record you build at this hearing is also what the sentencing judge will read, so it matters twice.
Do I get sentence credit for time spent on a probation hold?
Usually, yes, when the hold and the sentence arise from the same conduct. Wis. Stat. § 973.155(1)(b) counts as custody the days spent under a probation, extended supervision or parole hold placed under § 973.10(2) or § 304.06(3) for the same course of conduct that led to the new conviction or the revocation sentence. Credit is calculated day for day. Disputes arise over holds that overlap with a new case in another county or that relate to a different course of conduct, so we document the hold dates from the jail booking record and raise credit at sentencing rather than leaving it to a later motion.
How long do I have to file a criminal appeal in Wisconsin?
The first deadline is 20 days, and it runs from sentencing, not from entry of the judgment of conviction. Wis. Stat. (Rule) § 809.30(2)(b) requires that 'within 20 days after the date of sentencing or final adjudication' the person file in circuit court, and serve on the prosecutor, a notice of intent to pursue postconviction or postdisposition relief. That notice is not the appeal itself; it preserves the pathway. The postconviction motion or notice of appeal then comes later, due under § 809.30(2)(h) within 60 days after the later of service of the transcript or the circuit court case record. Missing the 20-day notice forecloses most direct-appeal rights, which is why consultation immediately after sentencing is critical. Collateral attacks under § 974.06 have longer windows but require a different procedural showing.
What can be appealed in a Wisconsin criminal case?
On direct appeal under § 974.02 / § 809.30: errors at trial (evidentiary rulings, jury instructions, sufficiency of the evidence), pretrial rulings (suppression denials, severance), sentencing errors, and ineffective assistance of trial counsel. On collateral attack under § 974.06: constitutional errors not previously raised, newly discovered evidence, and certain ineffective-assistance claims that could not have been raised on direct appeal.
What's the difference between an appeal and a § 974.06 motion?
An appeal under § 974.02 / § 809.30 is the direct-review pathway, started by the notice of intent that § 809.30(2)(b) requires within 20 days after sentencing, and it reviews the trial court record for legal error. A § 974.06 motion is a collateral postconviction challenge filed in the trial court, available after direct-appeal rights are exhausted, raising claims that could not have been raised on direct appeal. The two pathways have different deadlines, different review standards, and different available remedies.
What is the success rate for Wisconsin criminal appeals?
We do not publish a success-rate percentage, because the Wisconsin Court of Appeals does not publish one. Its monthly statistical reports at wicourts.gov break dispositions down by type (authored and per curiam opinions, summary dispositions, memorandum opinions, other terminations) and by district, not by outcome, so there is no official affirm-versus-reverse figure to quote. What the official data does show is volume: through July 2026 the court had terminated 1,721 cases and had 2,488 pending, 1,216 of them criminal. What actually moves an individual case is the strength of the issue: a preserved suppression ruling, a structural sentencing error, or a well-developed ineffective-assistance record. Most successful appeals produce a remand for a new trial or resentencing rather than an outright dismissal. Ask for a candid, issue-specific assessment rather than a percentage.
Will I go to jail for a probation violation in Wisconsin?
Not automatically. The Department of Corrections must initiate revocation proceedings under § 973.10, and at the final revocation hearing the State carries only a preponderance-of-the-evidence burden, lower than the trial standard. Reinstatement to probation with additional conditions is often available where revocation would otherwise mean time back in custody, particularly for technical violations rather than new criminal conduct. Preparation at the hearing matters more than most defendants realize.
Can I appeal a probation revocation in Wisconsin?
Yes. Revocation decisions by the Division of Hearings and Appeals are subject to certiorari review in circuit court under § 801.02. The standard of review is narrow (whether the decision was within jurisdiction, supported by substantial evidence, and not arbitrary), but it is a real check. The deadline is tight and comes from Wis. Stat. § 893.735(2): a certiorari action on behalf of a prisoner is barred unless commenced within 45 days after the cause of action accrues, which the statute sets at the date of the decision, extendable only by the number of days the prisoner proves passed before actual notice reached him. Post-revocation consultation should be immediate.
What happens at a probation revocation hearing?
Two-step process. A preliminary hearing first determines whether probable cause exists that a violation occurred. If probable cause is found, a final revocation hearing follows, conducted by an administrative law judge (ALJ) with the Division of Hearings and Appeals. The defendant has the right to counsel, to present evidence, to confront witnesses, and to testify. The State must prove the violation by a preponderance and demonstrate that revocation is appropriate.
How long does an appeal take in Wisconsin?
Direct criminal appeals typically run 12 to 24 months from notice of appeal to decision. Postconviction motions in the trial court can resolve faster (3 to 9 months) but often require evidentiary hearings on ineffective-assistance claims. Wisconsin Supreme Court review (discretionary, by petition) adds 6 to 12 months on top of court-of-appeals review. Defendants in custody may seek bail pending appeal under § 969.01(2).
Should I plead guilty if I plan to appeal?
Pleading guilty waives most direct-appeal issues. A defendant who pleads guilty preserves only sentencing challenges, claims that the plea itself was involuntary or unknowing, and certain ineffective-assistance claims. Suppression denials, evidentiary rulings, and most trial-related issues are waived by the plea. If you have appealable issues, raising them before plea is essential.
Can I appeal a sentence I think is too harsh?
Yes, but the standard is narrow. Wisconsin appellate courts review sentencing for an erroneous exercise of discretion: whether the trial court considered the proper factors (gravity of offense, character of the defendant, public protection), whether it considered improper factors, and whether the sentence is shockingly disproportionate. Sentence-modification motions in the trial court under § 973.19 are sometimes a more practical pathway.

Why Choose Cafferty

Free consultation icon

Free Consultation

From our offices in Racine and Kenosha Wisconsin, the criminal defense lawyers at Cafferty, Scheidegger & Johnson defend the rights of people charged with state and federal criminal offenses throughout Southeastern Wisconsin (Racine, Kenosha, Walworth). If you or a loved one is charged with a crime, contact us today to arrange a free initial consultation with an experienced Racine criminal defense attorney right away. For urgent matters, you are welcome to call or text us 24 hours a day at (262) 632-5000.

Aggressive defense shield icon

We Defend You

The attorneys at Cafferty, Scheidegger & Johnson have excellent knowledge of the state and federal court system throughout Southeastern Wisconsin. They are aggressive trial lawyers that are recognized for integrity and hard work. Our law firm’s strength lies in our exceptional pre-trial investigation and case preparation. We come to the prosecutor’s office prepared with the facts and ready to help you get the best possible outcome for your charges. Our priority is always to keep you out of jail and avoid a conviction on your record, whenever possible.

Proven experience badge icon

Proven Experience

The dedication of the team at Cafferty, Scheidegger & Johnson to client service and their record of success has earned them listings as Wisconsin Super Lawyer® from 2008 - 2026. In addition, their reputation for high standards has earned them an AV Preeminent rating by Martindale-Hubbell. Cafferty, Scheidegger & Johnson is backed by more than 32 years of trial skills and courtroom experience.

Contact us today for a free consultation

We are here to help you with your case questions.

Start your case review