A felony defined by someone else’s charge
Harboring or aiding a felon is an unusual charge: how serious it is depends on what someone else is accused of. Under § 946.47, helping a person accused of a Class A to D felony, which includes homicide and the most serious violent and drug offenses, is a Class G felony with up to 10 years. Helping a person accused of a lower-level felony is a Class I felony. It is often charged against friends, partners and relatives of the main suspect, people who have never been in a courtroom before and who did not think of themselves as part of anything.
We defend people charged under § 946.47 in Racine County Circuit Court at 730 Wisconsin Avenue and Kenosha County Circuit Court at 912 56th Street, from our offices in Racine and Kenosha. Our founding partner, Patrick K. Cafferty, has defended Wisconsin felony cases since 1994.
- Harboring or aiding, § 946.47(1)(a). Harbors or aids a felon with intent to prevent the felon’s apprehension.
- Evidence, § 946.47(1)(b). Destroys, alters, hides or disguises physical evidence, or places false evidence, with intent to prevent apprehension, prosecution or conviction.
- Class G felony if the felon’s offense is Class A to D, or an unclassified felony punishable by life, § 946.47(2m)(a): up to 10 years and $25,000, § 939.50(3)(g).
- Class I felony if the felon’s offense is Class E to I, or another unclassified felony, § 946.47(2m)(b): up to 3 years 6 months and $10,000, § 939.50(3)(i).
- “Felon”: a person who commits an act that is a felony in Wisconsin; no conviction is required, § 946.47(2).
What the State has to prove
For a charge under § 946.47(1)(a), the State must prove that another person was a felon as the statute defines it, that the defendant harbored or aided that person, and that the defendant did so with intent to prevent the person’s apprehension. For a charge under § 946.47(1)(b), it must prove that the defendant destroyed, altered, hid or disguised physical evidence, or placed false evidence, with intent to prevent the apprehension, prosecution or conviction of a felon.
Each element is a point of defense:
- Was the other person a “felon”? The State does not need a conviction, but it does need to prove that the person committed an act constituting a felony, § 946.47(2)(a). If that act is in dispute, so is this element.
- What was the help? Harboring and aiding mean more than being present, knowing someone, or sharing a home that was already shared.
- What did the defendant know, and when? Intent to prevent apprehension requires knowing there was an apprehension to prevent. Help given before the defendant learned of the accusation is a different matter from help given after.
- What was the purpose? A ride, a meal, a place to sleep or a phone can serve many purposes. The State has to prove the one the statute requires.
How the classification works
The class of the charge follows the offense committed by the person being aided, § 946.47(2m). That makes the main case part of this one. If the main charge is reduced, the classification of the harboring charge can drop from Class G to Class I, which lowers the maximum from 10 years to 3 years 6 months. If the main charge is dismissed or not proved, the “felon” element itself is in question. We follow the main case as closely as our own.
Evidence cases under § 946.47(1)(b)
The second paragraph of the statute covers physical evidence: destroying, altering, hiding or disguising it, or placing false evidence. These cases often involve phones, clothing, vehicles or weapons, and they depend on what the item was, whether it was evidence of a felony, and why the defendant handled it as he or she did. False statements to police are usually charged separately, as obstructing an officer under § 946.41.
How we approach the defense
- Fix the classification. We determine which paragraph of § 946.47(2m) the State is relying on and what the main charge actually is.
- Build the timeline. Messages, location data, call records and witness accounts establish what the defendant knew and when, which is usually the center of the intent question.
- Separate the defendant from the main case. The interests of a person charged with harboring and of the main suspect often diverge. Our client’s defense comes first.
- Address statements. Many of these cases are built on what the defendant told police during the search for the main suspect. Whether those statements are admissible is examined before anything else.
- Consider resolution carefully. A Class G conviction is a felony with lasting consequences for employment, housing and firearm rights. The classification and the elements are where a better outcome is usually found.
Call before you talk to investigators
People charged with harboring are often first contacted as witnesses. If police want to talk to you about where someone is or what you saw, call before you answer. Call (262) 632-5000, answered 24 hours a day, or contact Cafferty, Scheidegger & Johnson for a free and confidential consultation at 840 Lake Avenue in Racine or 7001 30th Avenue in Kenosha. Spanish-speaking clients can read this page in Spanish and speak with attorney Juan S. Ramirez directly.
Related practice areas
- Resisting and obstructing an officer
- Homicide defense
- Witness intimidation defense
- Bail and bond conditions in Wisconsin
- Bail jumping defense
Sources:
- Wisconsin State Legislature: § 946.47, Harboring or aiding felons
- Wisconsin State Legislature: § 939.50, Classification of felonies
- Wisconsin State Legislature: § 973.01, Bifurcated sentence of imprisonment and extended supervision
- Wisconsin State Legislature: § 946.41, Resisting or obstructing officer