Charges built on records, decided by statute
Wisconsin treats official misconduct as a felony. A public officer or employee charged under § 946.12 or § 946.13 faces a Class I felony, and a felony conviction carries a consequence most defendants never face: under Article XIII, Section 3 of the Wisconsin Constitution, it makes the person ineligible to hold public office unless pardoned. These charges reach elected officials, appointed board members, municipal and county employees, school district staff and anyone else who serves a public body.
We defend people charged under the official misconduct statutes in Racine County Circuit Court at 730 Wisconsin Avenue and Kenosha County Circuit Court at 912 56th Street, from our offices in Racine and Kenosha. Our founding partner, Patrick K. Cafferty, has defended Wisconsin felony cases since 1994. The work starts with the statute and the records the State relies on.
- Misconduct in public office, § 946.12. Five separately defined offenses, set out below. Class I felony.
- Private interest in public contract, § 946.13. A private pecuniary interest in a contract the officer or employee has an official role in. Class I felony.
- Bribery of public officers and employees, § 946.10. Offering or accepting an unauthorized advantage to influence official action. Class H felony.
- Class I maximum: 3 years 6 months and $10,000, § 939.50(3)(i); confinement up to 1 year 6 months, § 973.01(2).
- Class H maximum: 6 years and $10,000, § 939.50(3)(h); confinement up to 3 years.
- Eligibility to office: a felony conviction bars holding office unless pardoned, Wis. Const. art. XIII, § 3.
Misconduct in public office, § 946.12
Section 946.12 is not one crime. It lists five, and each has its own elements:
- § 946.12(1), failing to perform a duty. Intentionally failing or refusing to perform a known mandatory, nondiscretionary, ministerial duty of the office within the time or in the manner required by law.
- § 946.12(2), exceeding lawful authority. Doing an act, in an official capacity, that the officer or employee knows is in excess of lawful authority or knows is forbidden by law.
- § 946.12(3), exercising discretion for a dishonest advantage. Exercising a discretionary power in a manner inconsistent with the duties of the office or the rights of others, with intent to obtain a dishonest advantage for the officer or employee or another.
- § 946.12(4), falsifying records. Intentionally falsifying, in a material respect, an entry in an account, record book, return, certificate, report or statement.
- § 946.12(5), soliciting or accepting an unlawful fee. Under color of office, intentionally soliciting or accepting for a service or duty anything of value the officer or employee knows is greater or less than is fixed by law.
The knowledge and intent words in each subsection are elements the State must prove. The official annotations record that § 946.12(3) requires proof both that the conduct was inconsistent with the duties of the office and that it was done with intent to obtain a dishonest advantage, as separate elements, State v. Jensen, 2007 WI App 256. They also record that § 946.12(3) applies to acts under color of office and under de facto powers conferred by practice and usage, State v. Tronca, 84 Wis. 2d 68 (1978), and that a legislator’s duties can be determined from sources including policy manuals, statutes and legislative rules, State v. Chvala, 2004 WI App 53, affirmed 2005 WI 30. Under § 946.18, §§ 946.10 to 946.17 apply to public officers whether legally constituted or exercising powers as if legally constituted.
Private interest in a public contract, § 946.13
Section 946.13 is aimed at conflicts of interest in public contracting. It has two paragraphs:
- § 946.13(1)(a) applies when the officer or employee, in a private capacity, negotiates, bids for or enters into a contract in which he or she has a private pecuniary interest, direct or indirect, while being authorized or required by law to participate officially in making that contract or to exercise discretion regarding it.
- § 946.13(1)(b) applies when the officer or employee, in an official capacity, participates in making a contract in which he or she has that interest, or performs a discretionary function regarding it.
A contract made in violation of the section is void, § 946.13(3). Because the official annotations record that § 946.13(1)(b) is a strict liability offense without an element of corrupt motive, State v. Stoehr, 134 Wis. 2d 66 (1986), the defense in these cases usually turns on the elements that remain: whether there was a contract, whether the interest was private and pecuniary, what official role the defendant actually had in making it, and whether an exception applies. The annotations include two examples of how those elements are decided:
- A county board member who took a job. The member did not violate § 946.13(1) by accepting a job as airport manager for an airport the county co-owned, where he was appointed on the advice and approval of corporation counsel, State v. Davis, 63 Wis. 2d 75 (1974).
- A position that did not exist yet. A defendant could not have had a pecuniary interest in, or negotiated in a private capacity for, a position that had not yet been posted, State v. Venema, 2002 WI App 202.
The exceptions in § 946.13(2)
The statute does not apply to contracts in which a single officer or employee is privately interested that do not involve receipts and disbursements by the state or political subdivision aggregating more than $15,000 in any year, § 946.13(2)(a). It also excludes:
- deposits of public funds in public depositories;
- loans under § 67.12;
- legal notices published at the lawful rate;
- certain tax title and bond transactions;
- payments under listed conservation, farmland preservation and water quality programs.
Further subsections address small stock holdings, § 946.13(5); compensated bank directors and employees, § 946.13(7); and lawyers in firms that serve as counsel to the public body, § 946.13(11). Whether an exception applies is a question of statute and records, and it is one of the first things we examine.
Bribery, § 946.10
Bribery runs in both directions. Section 946.10(1) applies to whoever transfers or promises to a public officer or employee any property or personal advantage the officer or employee is not authorized to receive, with intent to influence official conduct or to induce a violation of lawful duty. Section 946.10(2) applies to the officer or employee who accepts or offers to accept that property or advantage under an understanding to act in a certain way. Both are Class H felonies. The official annotations record that intent to influence may be proved by circumstantial evidence, State v. Rosenfeld, 93 Wis. 2d 325 (1980), which is why the surrounding records and communications are central in these cases.
How we approach the defense
- Identify the subsection. A complaint that cites § 946.12 or § 946.13 without the subsection does not tell you what the State has to prove. We start by fixing the exact charge and its elements.
- Establish the actual duties. Many of these offenses depend on what the office required or authorized. We read the ordinances, statutes, policies, job descriptions and minutes that defined the role.
- Read the records in order. Votes, contracts, postings, emails and payroll records establish who did what and when. The sequence often decides whether the defendant had the official role the statute requires.
- Test the exceptions. The $15,000 threshold and the other § 946.13(2) exceptions are statutory defenses, not arguments for leniency.
- Challenge knowledge and intent. Where a subsection requires knowledge or a dishonest-advantage purpose, the State must prove it beyond a reasonable doubt.
- Protect eligibility to office. Because a felony conviction triggers Article XIII, Section 3, the classification of any resolution is weighed alongside the sentence.
Call before you answer questions
Official misconduct investigations often begin with an audit, a complaint or a news story, and they move from records to interviews. Call (262) 632-5000, answered 24 hours a day, or contact Cafferty, Scheidegger & Johnson for a free and confidential consultation at 840 Lake Avenue in Racine or 7001 30th Avenue in Kenosha. Spanish-speaking clients can read this page in Spanish and speak with attorney Juan S. Ramirez directly.
Related practice areas
- White collar crime defense
- Theft charge defense
- Money laundering defense
- Federal criminal defense
- Wisconsin tax fraud defense
Sources:
- Wisconsin State Legislature: § 946.12, Misconduct in public office
- Wisconsin State Legislature: § 946.13, Private interest in public contract prohibited
- Wisconsin State Legislature: § 946.10, Bribery of public officers and employees
- Wisconsin State Legislature: § 946.18, Misconduct sections apply to all public officers
- Wisconsin State Legislature: § 939.50, Classification of felonies
- Wisconsin State Legislature: § 973.01, Bifurcated sentence of imprisonment and extended supervision
- Wisconsin State Legislature: Wisconsin Constitution, Article XIII, Section 3, Eligibility to office